NRF24 project - a word of warning!
Posted: 03 Oct 2021, 10:26
OK, first don't panic (to use a well known phrase)! There's nothing fundamentally wrong with the project! There is, however, a "gotcha" in the setup, if you wish to remain strictly legal!
Our frequency allocation is 2400 to 2483.5 MHz. The output frequency of the module is determined by Fout=2400 + Channel Number MHz. This means that if you allocate any channel numbers above 83, you will be transmitting outside our allocated band, and could be placed on the "naughty" step if discovered!
To allow a suitable "guard band" at the band edges, I would suggest using channel numbers 1 to 82 (inclusive).
I think the UK band allocation is the same across most of Europe - certainly Sweden and France are the same. Outside of Europe, your mileage may vary, so check your local regulations and adjust the channel numbers accordingly!
I discovered this by accident when I looked at the output of my Ponty sweepstake prize on a spectrum analyzer. Speaking to Tobe, he'd just gone with Phil's original suggestions for channel allocations, unaware of the issue. I've contacted Phil about it, and he says that it was discussed in the original thread, but if I missed it and Tobe missed it, the chances are more of you have.
Tobe is now busy re-programming his own systems, and has kindly sent me an updated sketch for mine. I suggest that if you have programmed any channel numbers above 82, you do the same.
The chances of getting caught are remote, but we enjoy a relatively relaxed enforcement agency in the UK. I wouldn't want to see that jeopardised!
--
Pete
Our frequency allocation is 2400 to 2483.5 MHz. The output frequency of the module is determined by Fout=2400 + Channel Number MHz. This means that if you allocate any channel numbers above 83, you will be transmitting outside our allocated band, and could be placed on the "naughty" step if discovered!
To allow a suitable "guard band" at the band edges, I would suggest using channel numbers 1 to 82 (inclusive).
I think the UK band allocation is the same across most of Europe - certainly Sweden and France are the same. Outside of Europe, your mileage may vary, so check your local regulations and adjust the channel numbers accordingly!
I discovered this by accident when I looked at the output of my Ponty sweepstake prize on a spectrum analyzer. Speaking to Tobe, he'd just gone with Phil's original suggestions for channel allocations, unaware of the issue. I've contacted Phil about it, and he says that it was discussed in the original thread, but if I missed it and Tobe missed it, the chances are more of you have.
Tobe is now busy re-programming his own systems, and has kindly sent me an updated sketch for mine. I suggest that if you have programmed any channel numbers above 82, you do the same.
The chances of getting caught are remote, but we enjoy a relatively relaxed enforcement agency in the UK. I wouldn't want to see that jeopardised!
--
Pete